bullet  Home  bullet  Weather  bullet  World  bullet  Tropical cyclones  bullet  Forecast verification  bullet September 2004

Tropical cyclone activity and forecasts - September 2004

1. Tropical cyclone activity

1.1 Tropical cyclones ending during the month

NWP NEP NAT NI SWI AUS TOTAL
Total number ending during the month 4 3 6 0 0 1 14
 
Name Identifier Basin Start Date End Date 1-minute MSW 10-minute MSW
Frances 06L NAT 25 August 07 September 125 -
Songda 22W NWP 27 August 08 September 125 90
Gaston 07L NAT 27 August 01 September 60 -
Howard 11E NEP 30 August 05 September 120 -
Phoebe 01S AUS 02 September 04 September 55 50
Ivan 09L NAT 02 September 24 September 145 -
Sarika 23W NWP 04 September 07 September 60 55
Isis 12E NEP 08 September 17 September 65 -
- 10L NAT 09 September 09 September 30 -
Javier 13E NEP 10 September 19 September 130 -
Haima 24W NWP 11 September 13 September 30 40
Jeanne 11L NAT 13 September 27 September 100 -
Karl 12L NAT 16 September 24 September 120 -
Meari 25W NWP 20 September 30 September 120 90

Basin name abbreviations:-
NWP : North-West Pacific (west of 180°E)
NEP : North-East Pacific (east of 180°E)
NAT : North Atlantic
NI : North Indian (west of Malay Peninsula)
SWI : South-West Indian (west of 90°E)
AUS : Australian (east of 90°E)
1-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 1 minute (JTWC Hawaii, NHC Miami, CPHC Hawaii)
10-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 10 minutes (JMA Japan, Southern Hemisphere RSMCs and TCWCs)

Note: Although 1-minute average winds should be stronger than 10-minute average, this may not be the case here since estimates are obtained from different warning centres.

1.2 Tropical cyclones still active at the end of the month

Name Identifier Basin Start Date
Lisa 13L NAT 19 September

2. FORECAST ERROR STATISTICS

The Met Office global Numerical Weather Prediction model produces a 6-day forecast every 12 hours. The performance of the model in forecasting this month's tropical cyclones is assessed below. Mean error statistics for each storm that ended during the month are presented together with a final table of statistics for all storms ending this month. Verification is performed at 24 hour intervals up to forecast time T+120. Some mean error statistics for last year's storms are included for the purposes of a comparison. The present global model has a resolution of 0.83°x 0.55°x 38 levels. This is equivalent to a horizontal resolution of 93km x 62km at the equator.

Click here for details of the TC verification technique and an explanation of error statistics and their sign conventions.

2.1 Individual Tropical Cyclone Summaries

Name: FRANCES Identifier: 06L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 25.08.2004 End date: 07.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 125 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 24 22 20 18 16 14
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 1 -23 -94 -126 -158 -138
Mean DY 10 50 129 158 180 219
Mean AT 2 34 134 180 198 180
Mean CT 9 35 79 109 101 118
Track skill (%) **** 15 39 55 **** ****
Mean DPE 29 93 185 240 280 343
2003 DPE * 51 130 211 306 438 563
Intensity skill (%) **** 27 40 33 0 14


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NAT basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 00Z observed track and forecasts.

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 12Z observed track and forecasts.

Forecasts for Hurricane Frances were very good with all track errors below last season's average. Skill scores against CLIPER were positive. There was a slight fast and right-of-track bias. The fast bias was as a result of some longer range forecasts not predicting the slow down of Frances just before landfall over the USA. However, the location of landfall was very well predicted.

 

Name: SONGDA Identifier: 22W
Basin: NORTH-WEST PACIFIC
Start date: 27.08.2004 End date: 08.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 125 knots 10-minute MSW: 90 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 23 21 19 17 15 13
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 12 -21 -78 -258 -449 -502
Mean DY 5 -26 -141 -332 -561 -679
Mean AT -5 -45 -129 -241 -466 -664
Mean CT -1 -68 -124 -216 -313 -364
Track skill (%) **** 9 14 -19 **** ****
Mean DPE 42 147 270 472 756 897
2003 DPE * 54 150 251 359 498 643
Intensity skill (%) **** -5 -5 -6 -7 38


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NWP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Forecast errors were greater than last season's average at T+48 and beyond. There was a slow and left-of-track bias in forecasts. This was a result of many forecasts failing to predict recurvature.

 

Name: GASTON Identifier: 07L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 27.08.2004 End date: 01.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 60 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 8 6 4 2 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 **** ****
Mean DX -16 -5 36 144 **** ****
Mean DY -19 -20 142 72 **** ****
Mean AT -19 -16 123 167 **** ****
Mean CT 4 24 -78 19 **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 53 40 81 **** ****
Mean DPE 55 84 225 270 **** ****
2003 DPE * 51 130 211 306 438 563
Intensity skill (%) **** 0 50 100 **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NAT basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Forecast errors for this storm were near to or below last season's average. Skill scores against CLIPER were very high.

 

Name: HOWARD Identifier: 11E
Basin: NORTH-EAST PACIFIC
Start date: 30.08.2004 End date: 05.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 120 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 10 8 6 4 2 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 ****
Mean DX -3 8 7 71 219 ****
Mean DY -4 32 -4 -47 -23 ****
Mean AT 0 17 -8 -83 -140 ****
Mean CT -4 39 18 34 164 ****
Track skill (%) **** -4 31 31 **** ****
Mean DPE 38 85 139 223 225 ****
2003 DPE * 59 155 282 418 580 973
Intensity skill (%) **** 25 33 50 100 ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NEP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors for this storm were well below last season's average. The model showed skill over CLIPER at T+48 and T+72.

 

Name: PHOEBE Identifier: 01S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 02.09.2004 End date: 04.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 55 knots 10-minute MSW: 50 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 3 1 0 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 **** **** **** ****
Mean DX -121 -296 **** **** **** ****
Mean DY -11 -78 **** **** **** ****
Mean AT -75 -272 **** **** **** ****
Mean CT -37 143 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 124 308 **** **** **** ****
2003-4 DPE * 45 135 258 400 516 758
Intensity skill (%) **** -100 **** **** **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2003-4 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

This first storm of the southern hemisphere season was short-lived and just one forecast was verified.

Name: IVAN Identifier: 09L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 02.09.2004 End date: 24.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 145 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 29 25 23 21 19 17
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 12 38 31 29 61 103
Mean DY 5 35 109 189 283 416
Mean AT -5 -31 12 57 126 224
Mean CT 3 49 109 167 273 415
Track skill (%) **** 13 23 16 **** ****
Mean DPE 36 77 146 237 351 515
2003 DPE * 51 130 211 306 438 563
Intensity skill (%) **** 28 4 -14 -37 18


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NAT basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 00Z observed track and forecasts.

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 12Z observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors at all lead times were below last season's average and skill scores against CLIPER were positive for Hurricane Ivan. There was a persistent right-of-track bias in forecasts throughout the hurricane's lifetime. At lead times of 96 hours and shorter just one forecast erroneously predicted landfall over Louisiana. All other forecasts correctly predicted landfall over Alabama where Ivan eventually came ashore. No forecasts were verified during the brief phase when the remnants of Ivan regenerated over the Gulf of Mexico.

Name: SARIKA Identifier: 23W
Basin: NORTH-WEST PACIFIC
Start date: 04.09.2004 End date: 07.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 60 knots 10-minute MSW: 55 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 6 4 2 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 **** **** ****
Mean DX -12 19 41 **** **** ****
Mean DY -19 -63 195 **** **** ****
Mean AT -8 -108 172 **** **** ****
Mean CT -29 -28 101 **** **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 50 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 31 139 207 **** **** ****
2003 DPE * 54 150 251 359 498 643
Intensity skill (%) **** 50 100 **** **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NWP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors were below last season's average for this storm.

Name: ISIS Identifier: 12E
Basin: NORTH-EAST PACIFIC
Start date: 08.09.2004 End date: 17.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 65 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 16 14 12 10 8 6
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 80 88 67
Mean DX 4 -35 -135 -278 -500 -700
Mean DY 1 31 104 97 138 220
Mean AT -11 29 128 219 463 700
Mean CT 0 29 53 45 225 112
Track skill (%) **** 14 9 -14 **** ****
Mean DPE 46 127 253 365 589 767
2003 DPE * 59 155 282 418 580 973
Intensity skill (%) **** 14 50 0 71 0


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NEP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors were near to or below last season's average. Skill scores were positive at T+24 and T+48. Early forecasts had a fast bias and failed to predict the slow down which occurred near the end of the hurricane's life.

 

Name: - Identifier: 10L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 09.09.2004 End date: 09.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 30 knots 10-minute MSW: -
There are no verification statistics or forecast plot for this tropical cyclone since its 1-minute averaged winds did not reach tropical storm strength.

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track.

Name: JAVIER Identifier: 13E
Basin: NORTH-EAST PACIFIC
Start date: 10.09.2004 End date: 19.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 130 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 15 13 11 9 7 5
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 10 15 42 90 91 147
Mean DY 1 45 60 123 106 49
Mean AT -11 17 20 44 16 -58
Mean CT 1 31 60 129 99 124
Track skill (%) **** -25 8 8 **** ****
Mean DPE 39 96 152 229 240 253
2003 DPE * 59 155 282 418 580 973
Intensity skill (%) **** -8 64 33 43 100


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NEP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors for Hurricane Javier were well below last season's average, although skill scores were only just positive at T+48 and T+72. There was a slight right-of-track bias in forecasts.

 

Name: HAIMA Identifier: 24W
Basin: NORTH-WEST PACIFIC
Start date: 11.09.2004 End date: 13.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 30 knots 10-minute MSW: 40 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 3 1 0 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 **** **** **** ****
Mean DX -4 -20 **** **** **** ****
Mean DY 7 -56 **** **** **** ****
Mean AT 68 -60 **** **** **** ****
Mean CT 5 -11 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 92 62 **** **** **** ****
2003 DPE * 54 150 251 359 498 643
Intensity skill (%) **** 100 **** **** **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NWP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Haima was a short-lived tropical storm and just one forecast was verified.

 

Name: JEANNE Identifier: 11L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 13.09.2004 End date: 27.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 100 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 27 25 23 21 19 17
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 0 -53 -135 -125 -164 -265
Mean DY 15 69 110 165 223 349
Mean AT -9 26 109 119 74 -48
Mean CT 9 36 26 0 -15 16
Track skill (%) **** 24 44 63 **** ****
Mean DPE 45 114 209 253 382 700
2003 DPE * 51 130 211 306 438 563
Intensity skill (%) **** -4 4 43 5 6


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NAT basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 00Z observed track and forecasts.

Link to plot A plot of the storm's 12Z observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors for Jeanne were below last season's average up to T+96, but T+120 errors were large. Skill scores against CLIPER were positive. Early forecasts whilst Jeanne was still a developing tropical storm had a right-of-track bias and so did not predict the track across the Dominican Republic and Haiti. After re-emerging over sea and developing into a hurricane forecasts initially did not pick up on the extent of the eastward component of motion. However, later forecasts predicted the slow anti-cyclonic loop and westward movement towards landfall in Florida very well overall.

 

Name: KARL Identifier: 12L
Basin: NORTH ATLANTIC
Start date: 16.09.2004 End date: 24.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 120 knots 10-minute MSW: -

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 16 14 12 10 8 5
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX -18 -94 -140 -102 34 110
Mean DY -1 12 -11 18 279 267
Mean AT -16 0 -1 -12 255 294
Mean CT -12 -37 -45 -26 -55 85
Track skill (%) **** 33 49 57 **** ****
Mean DPE 57 155 239 300 309 421
2003 DPE * 51 130 211 306 438 563
Intensity skill (%) **** 14 17 40 50 -60


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NAT basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors were near to or below last season's average for this hurricane. Skill scores against CLIPER were high. There was a fast bias in longer range forecasts.

Name: MEARI Identifier: 25W
Basin: NORTH-WEST PACIFIC
Start date: 20.09.2004 End date: 30.09.2004
1-minute MSW: 120 knots 10-minute MSW: 90 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 19 17 15 13 11 9
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX -15 6 -19 -154 -279 -386
Mean DY 3 -3 6 -127 -259 -284
Mean AT -7 -36 -42 -195 -281 -173
Mean CT -4 27 61 17 -74 -166
Track skill (%) **** 45 39 30 **** ****
Mean DPE 40 94 219 416 667 759
2003 DPE * 54 150 251 359 498 643
Intensity skill (%) **** -6 -7 23 45 56


* DPE for all storms in the 2003 season in the NWP basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

As with Typhoon Songda, the model's early forecasts did not predict recurvature well resulting in forecast errors above last season's average at lead times of 72 hours and greater. However, later forecasts predicted recurvature well and skill scores against CLIPER were high.

2.2 Summary of all Tropical Cyclones

Mean error statistics for all tropical cyclones (of at least tropical storm strength) which have ended this month are shown below.
Total number of depressions ending this month:- 14
Number of storms used in statistics below:- 13

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 199 171 147 125 105 86
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 98 99 98
Mean DX -2 -18 -58 -102 -158 -193
Mean DY 3 24 53 41 49 85
Mean AT -8 -6 33 19 19 -8
Mean CT 0 16 27 28 30 50
Track skill (%) **** 22 33 37 **** ****
Mean DPE 43 110 204 304 440 600
2003 DPE * 55 149 249 355 491 612
Intensity skill (%) **** 10 30 30 12 21


* DPE for all Northern Hemisphere storms in 2003 season

Comments:

September was an active month for tropical cyclones as it usually the case and track forecast errors were below last season's average at all lead times. Skill scores against CLIPER were positive. Although individual tropical cyclones had track biases, the mean bias for all tropical cyclones was very small. The intensity tendency skill score this month was a fairly modest 16%.