bullet  Home  bullet  Weather  bullet  World  bullet  Tropical cyclones  bullet  Forecast verification  bullet April 2006

Tropical cyclone activity and forecasts - April 2006

1. Tropical cyclone activity

1.1 Tropical cyclones ending during the month

  NWP NEP NAT NI SWI AUS TOTAL
Total number ending during the month 0 0 0 1 1 2 4
 
Name Identifier Basin Start Date End Date 1-minute MSW 10-minute MSW
Hubert 21S AUS 05 April 07 April 55 55
Elia 22S SWI 12 April 16 April 45 45
Monica 23P AUS 17 April 25 April 155 135
Mala 02B NI 24 April 29 April 115 65*

* Incomplete set of advisories for 10-minute winds

Basin name abbreviations:-
NWP : North-West Pacific (west of 180°E)
NEP : North-East Pacific (east of 180°E)
NAT : North Atlantic
NI : North Indian (west of Malay Peninsula)
SWI : South-West Indian (west of 90°E)
AUS : Australian (east of 90°E)
1-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 1 minute (JTWC Hawaii, NHC Miami, CPHC Hawaii)
10-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 10 minutes (JMA Japan, Southern Hemisphere RSMCs and TCWCs)
Note: Although 1-minute average winds should be stronger than 10-minute average, this may not be the case here since estimates are obtained from different warning centres.

1.2 Tropical cyclones still active at the end of the month

None

2. FORECAST ERROR STATISTICS

The Met Office global Numerical Weather Prediction model produces a 6-day forecast every 12 hours. The performance of the model in forecasting this month's tropical cyclones is assessed below. Mean error statistics for each storm that ended during the month are presented together with a final table of statistics for all storms ending this month. Verification is performed at 24 hour intervals up to forecast time T+120. Some mean error statistics for last year's storms are included for the purposes of a comparison. The present global model has a resolution of 0.5625°x 0.375°x 50 levels. This is equivalent to a horizontal resolution of 62km x 42km at the equator.

Verification technique and an explanation of error statistics and their sign conventions

2.1 Individual Tropical Cyclone Summaries

Name: HUBERT Identifier: 21S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 05.04.2006 End date: 07.04.2006
1-minute MSW: 55 knots 10-minute MSW: 55 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 5 3 1 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 **** **** ****
Mean DX -19 -83 -227 **** **** ****
Mean DY -16 18 67 **** **** ****
Mean AT -15 18 -3 **** **** ****
Mean CT -22 -62 -240 **** **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 49 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 58 108 241 **** **** ****
2004-5 DPE * 41 130 225 344 549 737
Intensity skill (%) **** 100 100 **** **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2004-5 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Forecasts for this storm had a right-of-track bias. Errors were near to last season's average. Skill against CLIPER at T+24 was high.

Name: ELIA Identifier: 22S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date: 12.04.2006 End date: 16.04.2006
1-minute MSW: 45 knots 10-minute MSW: 45 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 6 4 2 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 **** **** ****
Mean DX 12 -8 -102 **** **** ****
Mean DY -32 61 117 **** **** ****
Mean AT -29 33 161 **** **** ****
Mean CT -24 42 47 **** **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 85 158 **** **** ****
Mean DPE 54 127 171 **** **** ****
2004-5 DPE * 40 169 252 341 566 761
Intensity skill (%) **** 50 -100 **** **** ****


* DPE for all storms in the 2004-5 season in the SWI basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Errors were below last season's average and skill scores high.

Name: MONICA Identifier: 23P
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (Coral Sea/Arafura Sea)
Start date: 17.04.2006 End date: 25.04.2006
1-minute MSW: 155 knots 10-minute MSW: 135 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 17 15 13 11 9 7
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 74 106 174 272 319 328
Mean DY 38 -8 -54 -120 -195 -212
Mean AT -13 10 83 161 121 -99
Mean CT 47 9 -26 -137 -225 -222
Track skill (%) **** 70 76 80 **** ****
Mean DPE 74 106 174 272 319 328
2004-5 DPE * 41 130 225 344 549 737
Intensity skill (%) **** 7 -23 9 -33 -43


* DPE for all storms in the 2004-5 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Track forecast errors were below last season's average for this cyclone and skill scores were very high. From just prior to first landfall, the model gave a good indication of the cyclone's north-westward turn once it emerged over the Gulf of Carpentaria. There was a slight right-of-track bias thereafter as the cyclone eventually made its second landfall over the Top End of Australia.

Name: MALA Identifier: 02B
Basin: NORTH INDIAN (Bay of Bengal)
Start date: 24.04.2006 End date: 29.04.2006
1-minute MSW: 115 knots 10-minute MSW: 65 knots

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 11 9 7 5 3 1
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 28 13 -134 -346 -729 -768
Mean DY 4 -1 -94 -229 -593 -467
Mean AT -5 -5 -30 -406 -921 -848
Mean CT 28 28 -77 -133 -182 -291
Track skill (%) **** 30 54 27 **** ****
Mean DPE 89 147 264 460 940 897
2005 DPE * 55 134 187 299 436 ****
Intensity skill (%) **** 11 -71 -60 -33 100


* DPE for all storms in the 2005 season in the NI basin

Link to plot A plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts.

Early forecasts for Cyclone Mala were poor as they predicted a slow cyclonic loop in the track. The cyclone eventually turned north-eastwards and made landfall over Myanmar. Poor initialisation due to lack of advisory data resulted in some forecast inaccuracies, with landfall predicted too far south at lead times of 48-72 hours. However, forecasts from 24 hours before landfall were good. Whilst track forecast errors were above last season's average skill scores against CLIPER were still high.

2.2 Summary of all Tropical Cyclones

Mean error statistics for all tropical cyclones (of at least tropical storm strength) which have ended this month are shown below.
Total number of depressions ending this month: 4
Number of storms used in statistics below: 4

Table of Mean Error Statistics
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 39 31 23 16 12 8
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 11 -17 -99 -181 -209 26
Mean DY 11 5 -46 -154 -295 -244
Mean AT -14 9 52 -17 -139 -192
Mean CT 22 12 -45 -135 -215 -231
Track skill (%) **** 51 68 73 **** ****
Mean DPE 73 121 204 331 474 399
2004-5 DPE * 41 147 237 343 556 746
Intensity skill (%) **** 23 -39 -13 -33 -25

* DPE for all Southern Hemisphere storms in 2004-5 season

Comments:
Track forecast errors were near to or below last season's averages. Skill scores against CLIPER were high. At longer lead times there was a slow bias and a left (right)-of-track bias in the northern (southern) hemisphere. The overall intensity tendency skill score was -11%.